I can’t look at the cover of The Eye of the World by Robert Jordan without flashing back to my thirteen-year-old self. I would devour the pages on the bus ride to and from school, tuning out the chatter around me to focus on the stubborn characters from the Two Rivers and their place in the Pattern. And I wasn’t the only one; I spotted other classmates toting the giant books around as well. The Wheel of Time was formative to my understanding of the fantasy genre, and I particularly loved the magic system. At the time, I didn’t see anything problematic about it.
[Spoilers follow for Robert Jordan’s Wheel of Time series and Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao]
My favourite scene from A Crown of Swords, the seventh book in the series, was when Nynaeve finally learned to channel the One Power without her block; as a wilder, she’d learned to channel by instinct, and even after training at the White Tower, she couldn’t access her powers without being angry. But finally, after seven books of struggling and refusing to “surrender,” because that’s what channeling the female side of the One Power requires, she’s stuck underwater with no way to escape. She has to surrender or die.
And with hope gone, flickering on the edge of consciousness like a guttering candle flame, she did something she had never done before in her life. She surrendered completely.
—A Crown of Swords by Robert Jordan
I liked this scene so much because Nynaeve’s inability to channel “properly” was a puzzle that needed to be solved. There were rules to Robert Jordan’s magic, and she wasn’t playing according to them. She was “cheating,” and as a result, she couldn’t always access her power when she needed to. Overcoming this block felt like a triumph, like positive character development—Nynaeve was always so mad and stubborn, and here she finally learned to give in.
Upon re-reading the series as an adult, this is now my least favourite scene in the entire series.
Buy the Book
The Eye of the World: Book One of The Wheel of Time
Jordan’s magic system is intricate and fascinating. The One Power has two sides—saidar, the female half, which is a gentle river that must be surrendered to or embraced; and saidin, the male half, which is a raging torrent that has to be dominated and controlled. Channelers weave flows of different elements: Earth, Spirit, Water, Air, and Fire. In addition to being more generally powerful than women, men tend to be better at channeling Fire and Earth, while women are better at Water and Air. Females are supposed to be able to compensate for their lower power levels by being more “dexterous” (however, upon re-reading the entire series, I still have no idea what that means, and several women are generally required to take on a single man of greater power).
Women are also able to link their powers—a feat men cannot achieve without them. This doesn’t result in their strength being combined; instead, the leader gets a bonus to their power and the other women in the circle cannot do anything. The main advantage is that the leader can form more complex weaves than they could manage alone. A circle of women can only be expanded beyond thirteen if a male channeler is added. And though a man cannot start a circle, a woman can pass control of a circle over to him once it has been formed.
All of these details add up to one fact: In the Wheel of Time series, gender essentialism is reality. It is built into the fabric of magic itself. Men’s superior strength in the One Power reflects how they are often physically stronger than women. Their need to wrestle saidin into submission, as opposed to women’s surrendering to saidar, reflects a view of men as dominant and powerful, while women are passive and submissive. Interestingly enough, I wouldn’t describe any of the female protagonists using either of those terms. Moiraine, often described as “steel under silk,” is wise, unyielding, and powerful, wielding Fire and Earth to great effect. Egwene, who has a special affinity with Earth, is stubborn and strong, persevering through the harsh training with Aiel Wise Ones and, later, withstanding torture. Elayne is imperious, unyielding, creative in learning how to make ter’angreal—a feat no one of this age had imagined possible—and takes on the weight of princess and, later, queen of Andor. Aviendha is a wildfire. Min is a rock. Cadsuane is a powerhouse.
In fact, if I could offer any critique of Jordan’s main female cast, it’s that they’re too similar—all incredibly stubborn characters with tempers who think men are wool-heads. It’s clear that Jordan does not think that a woman’s place is in the kitchen with a man ordering her around. The yin-yang symbol of the Aes Sedai and the way the One Power spikes when a female and male channeler work together suggests that he thinks men and women are stronger when they join forces, working together as equals. So why does his magic system subscribe to such binary gender norms?
In the scene with Nynaeve, Jordan missed an opportunity to push back against the “rules” of his world that say females need to be submissive. I wish that Nynaeve would have been allowed to wrestle with the One Power like men do. But perhaps he felt the binary nature of the laws he set in place prevented him. Or, more likely, he didn’t think about or recognize the option for a character to break the mold at all.
In the later books, the Dark One reincarnates Balthamel, a male Forsaken, into the body of a female (renamed Aran’gar). Aran’gar still channels saidin, the male half of the One Power. With Aran’gar, Jordan sets a precedent for how a person’s spirit, rather than their body, determines what half of the One Power they use, though this fact is never explored to a further extent with any other characters.
Robert Jordan published the first Wheel of Time book in 1990, and it’s clear he grew up understanding the world from a binary, cis-normative lens, not taking into account the fact that non-binary identities exist and that there are no traits that describe all women and all men. I love the Wheel of Time series, and I respect that Jordan created the fantasy world he wanted, but media doesn’t exist in a vacuum; the very fabric of Jordan’s world reflects gender stereotypes, perpetuating the idea that unequal social systems are natural. Re-reading this series made me wonder what such a binary magic system would look like if written today by an author who understood gender as a spectrum.
I recently picked up Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao, and my question was answered.
Iron Widow, which was released on September 21, 2021, takes place in a science fantasy world inspired by ancient China. The magic system (or as the author put it in an interview, the “magical-scientific” system), involves giant mechs called Chrysalises, which take the shape of mythical creatures, such as the Nine-Tailed Fox, the Vermilion Bird, and the White Tiger. It draws on the Chinese concept of qi, or life force, and Wuxing, the five elements of wood, fire, earth, metal, and water. Chrysalises require two pilots—a male, who sits in the upper “yang” chair, and a female, who sits in the lower “yin” chair.
Buy the Book
Iron Widow
I was immediately struck by the yin and yang imagery, which also appears in The Wheel of Time (as the emblem of the ancient Aes Sedai, in which the white teardrop shape represents female channelers and the black fang represents male channelers). Yin means “dark” or “moon,” and is associated with femininity. Yang means “light” or “sun” and is associated with masculinity. In ancient Chinese philosophy, yin and yang is a concept that describes how two opposite forces are complementary and connected, working in harmony.
But this concept is twisted in Iron Widow’s Chrysalises. Instead of working together to fight against the Hunduns (alien mechs bent on destroying humanity), the male pilot controls the Chrysalis. He uses the female pilot, also called a concubine, as a source of energy. More often than not, the female pilot dies during a battle, because the male’s mental energy overwhelms her.
To my delight, the story’s protagonist, Wu Zetian, asks the same question that immediately comes to my mind when the workings of the Chrysalises is described:
“What is it about gender that matters so much to the system, anyway? Isn’t piloting entirely a mental thing? So why is it always the girls that have to be sacrificed for power?”
—Wu Zetian, Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao
The novel opens with Zetian noticing a butterfly that has two different wings. Upon researching this phenomenon, she learns that this means the butterfly is both male and female. “Oh, yeah, biological sex has all sorts of variations in nature,” her friend Yizhi tells her, which leads Zetian to question what would happen if a person born like this butterfly piloted a Chrysalis. Which seat would they take? And what would happen if a woman took the upper yang chair or a man took the lower yin chair?
In this world, your “spirit pressure value,” the force with which you’re able to channel your qi, is measurable; when Zetian becomes a pilot, her test results show that her spirit pressure is six hundred and twenty-four, many times greater than most concubine-pilots. Such a high number means she might survive Chrysalis battles alongside a male pilot. She might even be an equal match for one of them, which would elevate her status in this patriarchal society.
Of course, no one knows what to do with Zetian when she not only takes control of the first Chrysalis she pilots, but her qi overpowers the male pilot and kills him.
Unlike Robert Jordan, Xiran Jay Zhao presents gender essentialism—the concept that men and women have specific, innate qualities related to their gender—as a social construct rather than a reality. By choosing ancient China—a society in which women were considered subordinate to men, often physically abused and forced to compete with concubines for their husband’s affections—as her inspiration for the setting, Zhao sets up Zetian to have the odds stacked against her. And that’s what makes the character’s rise to power such a breathtaking story. And while I won’t spoil the reveal, there’s more to the Chrysalises and Zhao’s magic system than meets the eye.
Interestingly, the yin-yang symbols used to represent channelers in the Wheel of Time don’t include the dots that suggest there’s a little bit of yang in yin and vice versa. Women are one thing and men are completely other. Iron Widow, however, embraces this mixture and does away with strict definitions.
“Female. That label has never done anything for me except dictate what I can or cannot do… It’s as if I’ve got a cocoon shriveled too tightly around my whole being. If I had my way, I’d exist like that butterfly, giving onlookers no easy way to bind me with a simple label.”
—Wu Zetian, Iron Widow by Xiran Jay Zhao
I appreciate the evolution that we can see between these two stories: first, a story that was written 30 years ago by a man who likely didn’t intentionally create gender barriers, but drew some hard lines anyway based on the restrictive societal norms he was familiar with; and second, a novel that was written this year by an author who intimately understands how society elevates certain identities for arbitrary reasons. Iron Widow demonstrates the distance we’ve traveled, in the last few decades, in the understanding and depiction of gendered magic systems, and proves that there’s room for all genders and LGBTQ+ identities in our stories. I can’t wait to see more magic systems like Zhao’s in future novels.
Allison Alexander edits sci-fi and fantasy at a small press, writes books, and plays video games the rest of the time. She is the incurable author of Super Sick: Making Peace with Chronic Illness, a geek’s guide to living with a disability. You can find her chasing bokoblins in Hyrule, traipsing with hobbits in Middle-earth, or blogging at aealexander.com.
I like your write-up and will read Iron Widon based off this.
You got the Wheel of Time Yin and Yang wrong though. The white Teardrop is for females, the black fang for males…
@1: I’ve updated the colors in the description, thanks!
The simple answer here is just the contrast of two different eras. For me, the question is not “So why does his magic system subscribe to such binary gender norms?” but, rather, why couldn’t there be a fantasy world where a gender binary is a part of the fabric of reality? That is not the case here in the real world, where I hope that one day everything and everybody is treated equally and the division that exists today is seen as barbaric. But I have no problem with works written in different eras and would have no problem in the future if an author wants to build a fantasy world on something like a gender binary, as long as the work isn’t a not-so-subtle way for the author to spread their hate/discrimination.
Wheel of Time’s magic system is gender essentialist. I don’t agree with that either but that’s what suspension of disbelief is all about.
However submission to Saidar isn’t at all about passivity. It’s about going with the flow and bending it gently to your will instead of fighting it into submission. Men who touch Saidar through a link with a woman often panic and drown as it rolls over them, just as women tend to panic when faced with the violence of Saidin. But men can learn to surrender to the female half of the power and direct it just as women can learn to master the violence of Saidin. The final lesson is men and women united, wielding both sides of the one power, are stronger than either is alone.
The overall theme of the Wheel of Time is that there are inherent differences in people and we are at our strongest when we recognize the differences and also recognize what each person contributes to work together. That theme is weakened if we eliminate or reduce the differences between the magic systems. If the systems aren’t different, the women don’t need the men and there’s no problem. The world is out of whack because of rampant misandry due to all the most powerful sorcerers being women and their inherent biases. It must be brought back into balance not by overthrowing them, but by men becoming strong again and finding balance. It’s clearly intended to gender flip Jordan’s perceived imbalance in our society and reach young men in particular so that they could spot gender imbalance and sympathize with the plight of women.
I still like that scene from Nynaeve. Nynaeve is not only learning to surrender, she is learning to work within her society to achieve her goals by expanding her tools to deal with the world. In the beginning she has only strategy, browbeat with competence and stubbornness until they see her point. Her growth with the power is mirrored by her increased social sophistication until she peaks with her gathering of an army for Lan. Early Nynaeve would have fought to keep him from going rather than accepting (surrendering to) his desires and controlling the outcome in that surrender.
I’m not saying the series is above criticism. I do agree that there could be more variety in the personalities of women. I also agree some aspects of his magic system that really do end up broken. I also loathe the message of working with the Seanchan (accepting the lesser evil) to beat the greater evil. However, if you remove the gender essentialism from the Wheel of Time you’re left with a bland series of young people powering up until they can take over and beat evil. There are dozens if not hundreds of unknown fantasy series treading this ground. The gender essentialism and deeper conflict it engenders is what makes the Wheel of Time so memorable.
Or rather, it appears to be. The Balthamel/Aran’gar situation suggests it is not, however. Balthamel can continue to channel saidin after his spirit is moved into a female body, suggesting the connection between channelling is linked to the soul, not biology. The Dark One can move his spirit into a new body but it is still limited by its prison, it can’t be creating some kind of weird conduit to allow Balthamel to channel saidin indefinitely despite being in the “wrong” place, biologically and genetically.
The implication from that subplot is you channel according to the identity of your soul, not your biology. The implications of that are fascinating but RJ decided not to explore them in the story because he had 3,000 characters and hundreds of other subplots and character arcs going on. But I think it’s also a sign that it’s not as essentialist as it first appears, and if RJ was writing the series today, he would definitely address those issues in greater depth (just as if he was writing it in the 1920s, he probably wouldn’t have even brought up the Aran’gar idea).
There could, and if the Wheel of Time was set on an actual alien planet (even the standard kind of fantasy one like Krynn or Toril or Midkemia where all the people just happen to be human and there are dogs and horses and swords and castles just like on Earth), that would be a worthwhile point. However, as RJ said and the narrative indicates several times, the WoT world is literally supposed to be our world, simultaneously in a distant future and a far more distant past. In a world where Mercedes-Benz, giraffes, 3D TVs, investment portfolios and radio telescopes exist or existed, it’s odd to suggest that biology and sociology works in a different way to what it does in the real world.
It should also be noted that the Wheel of Time started in 1990 (or 1984, when he started writing EotW), not a hundred years ago, and certainly nonbinary and trans people existed then as now, and were known about and talked about their experiences in the media. WoT had nonbinary fans from early on and I believe RJ was asked at various times about the gender essentialism in the series, and I believe the Aran’gar subplot was thrown in there specifically to say maybe there was greater complexity in play, but a thorough exploration of that was outside the scope of the series.
The Wheel of Time isn’t gender essentialist, it’s sex essentialist. As in biological sex. If you are born with XX chromosomes, you channel saidar. Born with XY chromosomes, you channel saidin. That simple. The fact that spirits can exist outside the body, as with souls the Wheel spits out from time to time (and Aran’gar is another example), does complicate it a little bit. Those setup some metaphysical questions about the way the Wheel universe works, but those are edge cases. When it comes to gender as a spectrum, I see no problems with how this works. Just because some have to wrestle saidin and some have to surrender to saidar does not encapsulate the rest of their attitudes and experiences. I can guarantee that there are men who channel that have a “go with the flow” attitude and there are women that have a “lets get this stuff done” view in the rest of their lives.
Thank you! So much food for thought, and a new book to add to my reading list!
@8: Except that when you are a disembodied soul, you have zero chromosomes at all, and channelling is clearly tied to the soul, not to any kind of genetic or biological status; in addition to the Aran’gar situation, there’s Rand having the same channelling potential as Lews Therin despite being in a completely different body (and Ishamael in Moridin’s body).
Trying to dismiss “edge cases” is always problematic, because in a population in the billions (as in the Age of Legends) or low hundreds of millions (in the “present” day of the series), there will always be far more “edge cases” than you think is likely. RJ himself noted this when he originally said around 3% of the population could channel, which sounds tiny, then realised that would give rises to a couple of million channellers in the Westlands alone in the present day (and potentially far more in earlier epochs), so he dramatically retconned that through various means to explain how the hell the Aes Sedai could only have 1200 members, which seems comically implausible when you think about it with realistic demographics in mind (to be fair, he made it a big part of the story that there’s a lot of untapped channelling talent out there, so he made it a virtue of the story).
I do think it’s fair to say that RJ did not explore all the facets and consequences of the worldbuilding in WoT (just as he didn’t set up proper language development, and made the Westlands far too huge for all the journey times to make sense, and never explained why the Seanchan travelled east to invade the Westlands when it was much closer travelling west), and because he is no longer with us clearly there can be no further canonical elaboration of the rules of channelling. However, it’s also fair to say that the publisher story does put some doubts under the essentialism of the magic system, and opens up areas where it’s interesting to speculate if the situation could be more fluid than it initially appears.
My biggest issue with gender essentialism in WoT is that it’s posed not as an alternate reality, but as an alternate interpretation of our own. There’s an implicit understanding that it’s not a different world with different rules, it’s just our world in a different age. This also implies that gender essentialism would be a reality of our world, One Power or not.
That is clearly wrong in so many levels, and it makes me itch every time I progress the story. What ever happened to all the queer people? The non-binary people? The trans people? I’ve been paying close attention to exceptions, and we do get mention of a couple of gay men and an off-handed reference to female-female sex (though labeled as an aberration and not part of the women’s identity). But that’s all, it’s like a reluctant after thought, like Robert Jordan didn’t really want to go there. I feel like the choice to not use swear words or any spicy language is related, he must have been extremely controversy averse for some reason. Maybe the intent was to make the story “kid safe”?
Anyway, I actually decided to comment for a completely unrelated reason. Clearly Iron Widon copied Darling in the Franxx. It’s exactly the same plot, just in a different time period and slightly different geographic location. It’s one thing to have similar ideas, but it’s the exact same idea, down to the details! I know we shouldn’t generalise, but this doesn’t help the stereotype that Chinese literature is plagiarised from the Japanese.
@11: Rather than framing the connection as “copying,” the author seems to be very open about the fact that Iron Widow grew out of their frustrations with the anime. In this interview, for example, when asked about the inspiration behind the novel:
1: It is White Flame of Tar Valon and Black Dagger.
No it’s the Flame of Tar Valon and the Dragon’s Tooth.
I have questions now about Iron Widow, I might have to check it out.
Incidentally, Wu Zetian is the name of historical China’s only female emperor and I wonder about the significance and/or implications of using that name.
Read over the comments… everyone forgets the forsaken that came back as a female but still channeled the male half. Jordan illustrates here that power is tied into a person’s soul, not gender.
“She’s channeling Saidin!!!” great moment in the books.
@16, Empress Wu was a piece of work. Rebelling against the patriarchy doesn’t automatically make you a Good Guy.
@16, Empress Wu was a piece of work. Rebelling against the patriarchy doesn’t automatically make you a Good Guy.
I think it’s worth pointing out that while RJ is doing the One Power thing, he’s also explicitly challenging the idea of coherent gender roles. He’s very clear that different cultures expect men and women to behave in different ways. What is correct behaviour depends highly on who you ask. Which seems as anti-essentialist as you can get
He’s not always successful in how he’s playing around with gender, but reducing his portrayal of gender to saidar and saidin is a disservice to the complexity of the text.
The gender dynamic should be “equal, but not the same.”
The fact that so many women in WoT are written in similar fashion told me when I first read it that it was an examination of how, regardless of gender, power corrupts. Only women can safely channel, so only women can safely command power. Most rulers, whether male or female, have Aes Sedai advisors, which perpetuates the idea that only women can safely command power in this world, whether magickal, temporal, or political. Of course powerful women will see most, if not all, men as woolheaded idiots.
As a young man, I was sexually harassed at work by a female supervisor, given a quid pro quo dilemma. Regardless of gender, power corrupts.
Iron Widow sounds like a much better version of what mecha anime have explored in various ways over the last few decades, just without the heavy and often disgustingly over-done fan-service mysoginistic sexualization of the female characters.
But IMMEDIATELY upon reading your description, I was reminded of the anime Vandread, especially since the critique is in regard to binary-gender-locked disparities.
Overall, great analysis.
Although one thing I did want to touch on was that you weren’t exactly accurate/ fair regarding saidar users Linking and how it DOES combine power, not exponentially, so much as cumulatively with diminishing returns. Which then yes, does directly make the circle-leader stronger, which does mean that their power is in essence combined. Like you understand the system but also contradicted yourself in regard to how you consider linking. The difference is that the “well of power available” allows for more intricate and complex weaves, than a single user, because they do “combine” their strength with others, and as we see and read in a few parts, that actually can lead to the head of a circle being able to over-exhaust those linked to her.
Something I think that deserves consideration is that the Damane are not taught to channel the way that Aes Sedai teach (the surrendering to the flow and opening of the flower petals bit) they’re merely taken and used by their Sul’dam. Then another thing to consider is that the Wise One’s direction to Aviendha and Egwene in regard to channelingprovides more agency, and to further on these extra-thought points for consideration the Atha’an Miere do not explain their Saidar learning process. The only recurring concept is that “surrender” is “required” althought wilders and Nynaeve’s anger prove the exception making the requirement null and void. Although, again that “surrender” is a White Tower Aes Sedai narrative, and the Wise Ones seem only to accept it. Lews Therin even never comments on the difference being quite so cut and dry and he has multiple flashbacks for Rand in which he does acknowledge the differences in capabilities and strength only, never ascertainment. So in a way I think RJ himself felt it was more directly controlled to willpower. Surrender is very much the same as forming the flame and void. Accepting what cannot be changed and reaching and directing what must be used. The only difference, is that Saidar is supposedly “more willing” yet we know that’s not always the case.
Also of note is that a certain Atha’an Miere Windfinder is able to “take” control from the head of the circle. Which adds further dynamic possibility to the uses of linking and how a link behaves. Which is of course neither here nor there in regard to compounded power, but it is something to consider when looking at the magic system of the One Power that RJ gave us, as otherwise you’re contrasting starkly.
You are also forgeting that in the Wheel of Time, the division of power was caused by the breaking, prior to it there was no division and anyone could control the whole one power regardless of gender. It is the mess caused by people that has caused the division, similar to the social constructs of gender seperation.
Tamara, what? No! That’s not true. The One power was always two sided and gendered. The Ancient Aes Sedai made the bore seeking a unitary power usable by both sexes. We all know how that worked out.
Respectfully, Allison, you may be thinking about the mechanics of the One Power TOO philosophically and forgetting that before he was the writer “Robert Jordan” James Rigney was a graduate of the Citadel with a background in engineering.
Jordan’s idea that men could “handle more of the power” but women were “more dexterous” has to do with energy efficiency. If Bob wanted to power a lightbulb with a batter but connected the two with a wooden stick, he would need a LOT of power in that battery to conduct enough electricity to power the bulb. If Alice wanted to light that same bulb but used copper wire instead of wood, she could accomplish the same feat with a smaller battery and far less heat waste.
The average Aes Sedi was weaker than the average Asha’man not just because she couldn’t channel as much of the One Power, but because the White Tower was frankly bad at training Aes Sedi to fight. Aes Sedai often culled powerful novices/accepted for stupid reasons of not being stoic and allowed many talented channelers to run away despite their claims otherwise.
Wise Ones were better at channeling without using unnecessary hand gestures than Aes Sedai. Sea Folk Windfinders could handle far more massive weaves, and the Seanchan used their poor Damane to a far more horrifying effect in battle. Any of these groups of women would probably be a better match for the average man in a fight than the average Aes Sedi was.
Per Jordan’s own discussions the most powerful woman couldn’t “hold as much” raw Saidar as the strongest possible man could hold raw Saidin, but she would be able to do roughly whatever he could with the Power and vice with about the same amount of mental/physical effort. Her weaves would be more efficient, he would make up for it by pumping more energy in to make up the difference.
The Wheel of Time is my favourite series but it isn’t above criticism. Jordan, for of his brilliance, was a very sexist man and a product of his time. Equality in literature is about more than having some strong female characters, it’s about how they are treated and in Jordan’s world they are a commodity.
Take Nyneave, originally she was my favourite character. Tiny spitfire, looked down upon for her youth, no cares about the interests of men. She wanted only to protect her community and do what was right. She was flawed and faceted, a character that reminded me of the strong women in my life. However, the moment she gets together with Lan what happens? She becomes obsessed with him and his happiness only. Her aspirations, her morals, common sense, and agency, all gone. She spent her time pining for him, simpering and all around became a weaker character. What a horrid fate! Finding love should strengthen people as they grow together, not weaken one for the sake of the other.
The same happened to a lesser extent to all 3 of “Rand’s women”. Not to mention the grossly sexist result that he ends up with 3 women who agree to “share” him. Mormon polygamy much? Had they been represented as equally in love with each other, not friends or sisters but lovers in their own right, it could have been a healthy representation of polyamory.
So while it’s disappointing that Jordan didn’t test the boundaries of the binary, it isn’t surprising. Given the time frame of release, his own age, and the other less desirable sexism in the series, the books are a good step forward in mainstream fantasy.
We can’t hold media of the past to the social standards of today. We can only use them as a learning/teaching experience and enjoy them while recognizing that criticism can come from a place of love for the media.
Rigney was a graduate of the Citadel, an all-male (and proud of it) military academy. I am amazed at the way people go into deep denial about the profoundly essentialist worldview from which he wrote. I remember talking to the guy decades ago when he was just another regional SF/fantasy writer attending Chattacon to meet fans. He flatly thought that the differences between men and women were hard-wired, and that anybody claiming otherwise was just being politically correct. His contempt for people who believed that it was more complex than that dualism was quite evident. The whole “you may be in a female body, but your REAL identity is male” thing in the WoT was not even vaguely subtle, nor did he mean it to be.
I agree with the person that says this is not gender existentialism, it is sex existentialism. The idea that a soul is sexed rubs people the wrong way, we think of a soul as being the essence of who we are as a person and that is more synonymous with what we understand gender to be. When Aran’gar is put into a female body, he begins to change, he begins to feel like a “woman”, this also rubs people the wrong way because they think gender is immutable and separate from their sex, it is why transgender people have dysphoria. But this is not necessarily true, that dysphoria is mitigated by hormones, and by apparent (visual) changes to the sex of the body indicating a mix of physical and psychological influences on gender. On top of the fact that 99% of everyone is cis doesn’t indicate that almost everyone is lucky, only that their gender conforms as it develops to the physical and psychological influences.
Jordan’s magic being seemingly tied to the soul and some kind of sex existentialism is not problematic, it is also not a “product of the time”. It represents the same basic truths of reality which caused our species to construct genders in the first place. Males being aggressive and that being assigned as a masculine gender trait isn’t some coinflip of some ancient human ancestor. It has biological and evolutionary roots. Maintaining the psychological category and prescriptive social pressure to keep the idea of a masculine gender is what is problematic in todays society.
To be clear up front: I see flaws in WoT. The work is not perfect. I do have a few quibbles:
“…it’s clear he grew up understanding the world from a binary, cis-normative lens, not taking into account the fact that non-binary identities exist…”
True. Relative to the genre, however, he was already inverting much of the traditional male/female power dynamic. So we’re left in the situation where we’re criticizing work that was forward-thinking by the 1980s/1990s standard of the times, on the grounds that it’s not forward-thinking enough by 2020s standards. One might be left to wonder if the work would be different if he started it today.
“Men’s superior strength in the One Power reflects how they are often physically stronger than women. Their need to wrestle saidin into submission, as opposed to women’s surrendering to saidar, reflects a view of men as dominant and powerful, while women are passive and submissive.”
It also represents two different views of strength in general. One might look to the differences in martial arts for a parallel. Karate and Kung Fu are one sort of discipline, Judo and Tai Chi are another sort. One sort may be more useful in some situations, but that does not make either sort superior to the other overall. In fact, I could as easily argue that men’s approach to their half of the One Power reflects a view of men as tending toward “brute force”, while women’s approach reflects a more thoughtful view that uses the force inherent in the One Power itself to direct it.
The Iron Widow had an interesting concept but does not execute it well at all. It’s poorly written, the characters are ridiculous, the main character is a murderous psychopath and somehow we’re supposed to be cheering her on as a hero. I really don’t understand why this book is receiving so much positive hype and attention. If it was a villain story, maybe? But it’s not. It’s presented as a serious feminist book, which it is not. It’s actually one of the worst “feminist” books I have ever read and it’s really starting to piss me off that this crap book is showing up EVERYWHERE and being lauded as this amazing work of art. The world building/war/magic systems are barely explained. People are applauding it for its polyamorous relationship, but it’s just a poorly crafted instalove scene no better than any other cheap YA instalove. Wu Zetian is a total Mary Sue, but instead of saving the world she burns it to the ground, murders anyone who stands in her way (including her own family), and turns into a dictator. If you gender swapped this book it would never be published. Just think about that for a moment. I know a story about a radical female in a patriarchal system fighting back is supposed to be empowering, but if a young male character cannot carry the same plot that this young female character does, I think we have a problem. A teenage boy couldn’t avenge his brothers death by killing and torturing women while dating two girls and then burn the Capitol and take over the world. No one would be okay with that being a YA novel. If you go read the one and two star reviews on GoodReads plenty of people have well written reviews about everything wrong with this “book”.
@5 on accepting the lesser evil. If I may draw a real world parrallel we did team up with Stalin to fight Hitler in WWII and Stalin was a pretty nasty piece of work
I think you’re letting Jordan off the hook a bit too easily here. Jordan’s reliance on gender essentialism was lazy at best (but then, so was a lot of his writing, lazy and repetitive). Themes of gender, expression, and roles have been around as long as modern sci-fi and fantasy have been; they’ve been fundamental themes since its inception, and tackled by writers older (and better) than Jordan. Some even before he was born, and a whole lot well before he started publishing (or likely even writing) Wheel of Time. Ursula K. LeGuiin’s Hanish cycle stories published in the ’60s and ’70s jump immediately to mind. The ’70s and ’70s were something of a golden age for work that broke out of the sexist, essentialist views that characterized mainstream culture and much of earlier sci-fi and fantasy work; and certainly would have been available to Jordan during his formative years.
I remember reading the Tales Of Earth Sea and being simultaneously bored to death and struggling to follow what was happening
Namea, I must beg to differ. Far from becoming obsessed with Lan Nynaeve puts him and their relationship on a back burner as she addresses the hunt for the Black Ajah, developing her healing abilities and of course bullying everybody in sight because she’s terribly insecure, which has nothing to do with Lan who’s a bundle of issues himself.
Elayne tends to ask about Rand when she gets the chance but she’s busy hunting Black Ajah, figuring out how to make Ter’angrael, and of course winning her throne! She also develops her relationship with Aviendha from best friendship to a deep sister bond which has nothing to do with Rand. Aviendha spends more time obsessing over feelings for Rand because they conflict with her feelings for Elayne. Until they are able to discuss the problem and agree that they can share Rand. With that out of the way Aviendha is free to quest for the Bowl of Winds, work on her relationship with Elayne and on becoming a Wise One. Min spends the most time with Rand and is the most focused on him but that doesn’t keep her from digging into esoteric philosophy and becoming an expert on the ins and outs of the Bore and the Seals.
As for Rand, he accepts that he is outnumbered and can expect to be thoroughly henpecked, and plans to enjoy it. He doesn’t even know when he’ll see any of his wives again, as he rides off into the sunset, being fully aware that all three have heavy responsibilities tying them down.
@BenW: Ursula K. LeGuin looked back on the original Earthsea trilogy decades later, and realized the trap she had set for herself. The later novels and stories, culminating in The Other Wind, go a long way to address why the School on Roke Island did not accept women, and what happened when the dragons, wizards, and women came together to understand what had gone wrong.
Other gender-based magic series: Darkover? Melissa Scott’s Silence Leigh trilogy?
I am a great fan of The Wheel of Time and consider it one of the greatest pieces of literature.
The One Power, the force that drove the Wheel that allows time to flow and the world to change. I always liked the concept that it was made up of two parts that had to work together.
This was shown in the story that the greatest works were always done by men and women working together.
With Balthamel/Aran’gar we were shown that which side of the One Power someone could use was based upon the Spirit/Soul rather than the body, When Balthamel first received his female form he could not channel but was told “The Spirit shapes the Body but the Body shaped the Mind” (Not an exact quote). In time his spirit would alter his body to allow him to channel, but also her body would alter his mind to adapt to it.
We saw with Nynaeve repairing the ability to channel it was visualized as connecting a bridge between the person and the one power, also that using the other power to what the person used created a stronger connection.
So where do Souls come from, it seems that they are created/birthed initially by the Power One and that would imply that Saidar and Saidin are present in stronger proportions and that could be what determines Affinity of the Spirit and this determines what sex a body becomes.
Beyond all this though is that it is a great and enjoyable story and people should just read and enjoy it and not worry about this, although it can be fun to talk about. I always like thinking about Rand’s “Awakened Dreamer” (my term) power at the end, that he has gone beyond Saidar and Saidin and that what he wills simply manifests.